The everyday infantry droids in the Star Wars prequels and The Clone Wars TV series are dumb as rocks. They are constantly confused, hoodwinked and bamboozled by paper-thin schemes, when they aren't tripping over their own feet into disaster. Yet more advanced droids, like assassin droids, protocol droids and astromechs like C-3PO and R2-D2 are highly intelligent, and referred to as "a dime a dozen" by Obi-Wan (Downfall of a Droid, Clone Wars 1-6). Is there an in-universe explanation of why the Separatists don't equip the infantry droids with better programming?
Answer
B1 battle droids are less intelligent because they didn't need to be smart, nor were they designed to be. As a matter of fact, they were originally designed to be coordinated by a Droid Control Ship which would coordinate and direct their strategy, fire patterns and overall tactical movement.
B1 Battle Droid's Role in Combat
The B1's role in combat was to keep blaster fire in the air, absorb damage and buffer incoming fire until more powerful and dangerous droids could be deployed.
After the battle of Naboo, control ships were considered problematic and potentially vulnerable so B1s were forced into semi-autonomy which caused them to behave erratically. Not every B1 Battle Droid was erratic, some through better programming were capable of being leaders, commanders or even commando droids.
To supplement their capacity, Super Battle Droids were created. Super Battle Droids and Droidikas were far more powerful, adaptable, and intelligent. Like any other specialized force, if supported properly, in this case by thousands of B1, such specialist droids could be used to devastating effect against enemy troops.
Was a lack of brainpower a handicap to the B1?
B1 battle droids did not NEED to think, and they weren't INITIALLY designed to think. They had leaders, handlers, or control software to direct their movements in whatever terrain they found themselves in.
B1 battle droids were designed to respond to environmental feedback (other troops, terrain and whatever weapons they had at hand) toward the destruction of their enemies. They didn't need to be particularly bright, their machine programming was more than adequate for most of their missions and could be upgraded over time.
What the B1 battle droid lacked in brainpower, they made up for in numerical superiority. In battle with living enemies, the B1 would be a terrible foe, if for no other reason, their ability to simply absorb damage and continue to press forward.
If B1 and other droids arrived in the proper numbers, it would take a force with a significantly greater power profile to stop their advance. Even adding Jedi to a defending force was often no guarantee of the defenders surviving.
Say what you like about the supposedly idiotic B1 battle droid; in the field, they were able to keep a rain of blaster fire on the enemy, suppressing their movement, tactics and their fire, allowing more potent droids the opportunity to get close, tear into the defenders and simply allow the B1s to pour through any hole created. In terms of strategy, it's simple, but like army ants, the B1 battle droid used it quite effectively.
Comments
Post a Comment